Sparkling Vintage Fiction. Among other things.

Sparkling Vintage Book Review: On Shifting Sand by Allison Pittman

on shifting sandWhile engrossed in Allison Pittman’s latest novel, On Shifting Sand, I continually found myself heading to the kitchen for a tall, cool glass of water to slake my thirst. Yes, it’s been a dry, hot summer here in Idaho, I told myself, but what gives? Then I realized that the cause of my thirst was Allison’s vivid, you-are-there descriptions of daily life in Oklahoma during the Dust Bowl of the 1930s.

“We feel thirst everywhere,” she writes in protagonist Nola’s viewpoint, “–our parched throats, of course, and the corners of our mouths. It seems, sometimes, that we are drying up from within. Our lungs rasp with every breath, our bones threaten to snap themselves to powder. There is not enough water to drink, to wash, to bathe. We are never quenched. we are never clean.”

Gaaack! Pass the pitcher!

Of course, I’d heard about the Dust Bowl (or Dirty Thirties, as they’re sometimes called). I’d read Steinbeck’s The Grapes of Wrath along with millions of other American high-schoolers over the years. But On Shifting Sand gave me my first glimpse in up-close detail what it was like to live through it, day by day. My ancestors experienced the Great Depression in other contexts, but not the dust storms that plagued the Great Plains. No wonder so many “Okies” packed up and left–for most of them, there was literally no other alternative. The storms took away their homes, their livelihoods, and even people they loved.

As I read On Shifting Sand, the descriptions of storms kept me riveted, almost as if the weather was a character unto itself.

This was important, because I found it hard, if not impossible, to warm up to Nola, a pastor’s wife in a small Oklahoma town. While I sympathized with the near-impossibility of keeping a clean and healthy home in the constant dust storms, and to feed her children on practically no income, her constant complaining and chronic dissatisfaction with her lot in life wore on my nerves. When a drifter comes to town and she makes terrible choices to try to make herself feel better . . . well, at that point, many good Christian readers may have closed the book.

And that’s too bad. Because Nola’s story has much to teach us about ourselves.

You see, when we’re not vigilant–and sometimes even when we are–sin comes upon us like those dust storms. It seeps into every crack and crevice of our lives, no matter how hard we try to keep it out, to scrub it away. Only the Living Water, Jesus Christ, has the power to wash it away, quench our thirst and make us clean again.

That, I believe, is the point of the story. Nola grew up in a home without love, and went looking for love in all the wrong places, as the old song goes. To escape an unhappy home life, she made a hasty marriage. (The title hearkens to Jesus’s parable about the foolish man who built his house on sand,
“and the winds blew and beat against that house, and it fell, and great was the fall of it.”) Now she’s restless, unhappy, and critical toward her husband, her two children, and the people of her town. When the handsome drifter–an old friend of her husband–comes to her home, her poor choices make everything infinitely worse. (In keeping with Christian publishing standards, we aren’t offered graphic details of what happens–needless to say, the picture’s clear enough.)

Ultimately, On Shifting Sand is a story of repentance, forgiveness, and redemption. You may have to slog through some dust and dirt to get there, but it’s worth it.

Disclosure: I’ve been given a review copy of this book by the publisher. This generosity, while appreciated, has not biased my review. I also post some of my reviews on Amazon and Goodreads.

 

6 Responses to Sparkling Vintage Book Review: On Shifting Sand by Allison Pittman

  • Jennifer says:

    Cathy, it did resolve well and, I think, realistically, But it kept me wondering. Definitely not run-of-the-mill fare, that’s for sure.

  • Elspeth says:

    Sounds like a good read. Gonna put it on my list. I found it interesting your note about where a “good Christian reader” might close the book. This is something I’ve considered often in my reading of diifferent genres. I’ve touched on it a bit right here:

    https://terrysbookobsession.wordpress.com/reading-standards/

    Basically, I either read through it quickly or just skip to the next page if it’s enough to affect me. It sees in the book you’re reviewing here that it wasn’t particularly problematic. However, the demarcation for me is whether the reality and consequences of bad choices is apparent for the reader to learn from.

    I haven’t read very any books concerning the dust bowl era, and this book sounds like as good as any to start with. Thanks for the review, Jennifer. I’m always on the lookout for good books that I don’t have to go back to the 19th century or very early 20th century to find, 🙂 .

    • Jennifer says:

      I do think the controversial parts were handled sensitively, and were germane to the story. If you read it, I’d love to hear what you thought.

      I really like your reading-standards post. I may use it as an example to create my own statement, if that’s all right with you. 🙂

Newsletter
Twitter!
Facebook!
Amazon